New on Android

MacroCodex is live on Google Play.

Download the free Android app to keep tracking your TDEE, body weight, calories, and macros in one place with no subscription.

Get MacroCodex

Estimated reading time: 9 min

The "Best" Workout Split for YOU: An Evidence-Based Guide

The fitness world is awash with "best" workout splits but the truth is, there's no single perfect answer for everyone. The optimal training split depends primarily on two critical factors: your training experience level and the number of days per week you can consistently train.

This guide will delve into the scientific evidence behind different training frequencies and splits, helping you make an informed decision to maximize your muscle growth (hypertrophy) and strength gains.

Key Principles Guiding Split Selection

Before we dive into specific splits, let's establish the foundational principles supported by research:

  1. Training Frequency for Hypertrophy: For muscle growth, hitting each muscle group at least twice per week appears to be superior to once per week. This is largely due to the sustained elevation of muscle protein synthesis (MPS) following a workout.
    • Evidence: A meta-analysis by Schoenfeld et al. (2019) concluded that "training a muscle group two times per week resulted in greater hypertrophy than training once per week." While the benefits diminish beyond 3-4 times per week for most, twice weekly is a strong baseline.
    • Mechanism: MPS is elevated for approximately 24-48 hours after resistance training. By hitting a muscle group more frequently, you create more opportunities to stimulate this muscle-building process throughout the week.
  2. Training Volume: Total weekly volume (sets x reps x weight for a muscle group) is a primary driver of hypertrophy. The "best" split helps you accumulate sufficient effective volume without excessive fatigue in a single session.
    • Evidence: Numerous studies, including Schoenfeld et al. (2017), have shown a dose-response relationship between volume and hypertrophy, meaning more volume (up to a point) generally leads to greater gains.
  3. Intensity and Recovery: While high frequency is beneficial, each session still needs to be challenging enough to stimulate adaptation. Adequate recovery between sessions for a given muscle group is crucial to prevent overtraining and optimize performance.
  4. Individualization: Genetics, lifestyle stressors, sleep, and nutrition all influence recovery and adaptation. What works perfectly for one person may not for another.

Picking Your Perfect Split: Based on Experience & Frequency

Let's break down the optimal splits based on your current training level and how many days you can commit:

Level 1: The Novice Lifter (0-6 months consistent training)

Characteristics: Rapid gains in strength and muscle. Highly responsive to training. Learning fundamental movement patterns is key. Recovery is generally excellent.

Evidence Rationale: Novices can make excellent progress with relatively low volume and high frequency because their recovery capacity is high and their bodies are highly sensitive to new stimuli. A full-body approach is ideal for learning proper form and maximizing frequency.

  • 1-2 Days/Week:
    • Recommended Split: Full Body (1-2x/week)
    • Description: Each session trains all major muscle groups. Focus on compound exercises.
    • Why it's "Best": Maximizes frequency for the limited training days, ensures all muscles are stimulated, and is time-efficient. Ideal for learning movement patterns.
    • Example (2x/week):
      • Workout A: Squat, Bench Press, Barbell Row, Overhead Press, Bicep Curls, Tricep Pushdowns, Planks
      • Workout B: Deadlift, Dumbbell Press, Lat Pulldown, Lunges, Calf Raises, Face Pulls, Ab Rollouts
  • 3 Days/Week:
    • Recommended Split: Full Body (3x/week)
    • Description: The gold standard for novice strength and hypertrophy. Hit each muscle group three times a week with compound movements.
    • Why it's "Best": Optimal frequency for rapid novice gains, allows for significant weekly volume distributed evenly, and promotes excellent skill acquisition for compound lifts.
    • Example (3x/week, alternating A/B):
      • Workout A: Barbell Squat, Bench Press, Barbell Row, Overhead Press, Core
      • Workout B: Romanian Deadlift, Incline Dumbbell Press, Lat Pulldown, Lunges, Face Pulls
  • 4+ Days/Week:
    • Recommended Split: Full Body (3x/week) OR Upper/Lower (4x/week)
    • Description: While full body 3x is still excellent, if you have more time, an Upper/Lower split allows for slightly more volume per session and longer rest for specific muscle groups.
    • Why it's "Best": Provides optimal frequency (each group 2x/week) with more dedicated time for upper and lower body exercises. Still beginner-friendly.
    • Example (Upper/Lower 4x/week):
      • Monday: Upper (Bench, Row, OHP, Pull-up, Bicep, Tricep)
      • Tuesday: Lower (Squat, RDL, Leg Press, Leg Curl, Calf)
      • Wednesday: Rest
      • Thursday: Upper (Incline DB Press, Cable Row, DB Shoulder Press, Lat Pulldown, Lateral Raise)
      • Friday: Lower (Deadlift, Lunges, Leg Extension, Glute Ham Raise, Abs)

Level 2: The Intermediate Lifter (6 months - 2+ years consistent training)

Characteristics: Gains are still consistent but slow down. Requires more volume and variety to progress. Recovery needs are higher than novices.

Evidence Rationale: Intermediates generally benefit from hitting muscle groups 2-3 times per week, with increasing volume and potentially more exercise variety. PPL and Upper/Lower splits become very effective here.

  • 3 Days/Week:
    • Recommended Split: Full Body (3x/week)
    • Why it's "Best": Still highly effective. You'll likely use heavier weights and add more sets/exercises compared to your novice full-body routine. The benefits of high frequency remain strong.
    • Progression: Focus on progressive overload (more weight, reps, sets) and potentially add an extra isolation exercise per muscle group.
  • 4 Days/Week:
    • Recommended Split: Upper/Lower (4x/week)
    • Description: Two upper body days, two lower body days. Each muscle group hit twice a week.
    • Why it's "Best": Excellent balance of frequency, volume, and recovery. Allows for significant volume for upper and lower body, making it a staple for many.
    • Evidence: Studies often compare similar total weekly volumes across different frequencies, and 2x/week frequency (as provided by upper/lower) consistently performs well for hypertrophy.
  • 5-6 Days/Week:
    • Recommended Split: Push/Pull/Legs (PPL) (2x per week cycle) OR Upper/Lower/Full (hybrid)
    • Description (PPL):
      • Push: Chest, Shoulders (anterior/medial), Triceps
      • Pull: Back, Biceps, Rear Delts
      • Legs: Quads, Hamstrings, Glutes, Calves
      • This typically runs as PPL, Rest, PPL, Rest (6 days on, 1 day off, or a more flexible 3 days on, 1 day off cycle). Each muscle group is hit twice every 7-8 days.
    • Why it's "Best": PPL allows for high weekly volume per muscle group by grouping synergistic movements. It's popular for a reason, it effectively combines frequency with focused daily workouts. The higher number of training days can be advantageous for accumulating volume if recovery allows.
    • Evidence: While some early studies suggested diminishing returns for frequency beyond 2x/week, PPL allows for slightly higher effective frequency across the cycle (e.g., 2x per 7-8 days) and excellent daily focus.
    • Consideration: Requires high commitment and good recovery. If you miss a day, it can throw off the entire cycle.

Level 3: The Advanced Lifter (2+ years consistent training, significant strength & muscle base)

Characteristics: Gains are very slow and hard-won. Requires highly individualized programming, meticulous attention to volume, intensity, and recovery. May benefit from even higher frequencies for specific lagging body parts or undulating periodization.

Evidence Rationale: Advanced lifters may need to manipulate training variables more precisely. While 2x/week frequency is still a strong baseline, some advanced lifters may benefit from slightly higher frequencies for specific muscle groups or highly specialized approaches. The "best" split here is highly personal and often changes.

  • 3-4 Days/Week:
    • Recommended Split: Upper/Lower (4x/week) or Full Body (3x/week, very high intensity/volume)
    • Why it's "Best": These tried-and-true splits remain effective. Advanced lifters will simply push the intensity, incorporate more advanced techniques (e.g., dropsets, supersets), and potentially increase the volume per session. Recovery becomes paramount.
  • 5-6+ Days/Week:
    • Recommended Split: PPL (2x per week cycle), Body Part Split (higher frequency than traditional bro-split) or Hybrid Splits (e.g., Upper/Lower/Push/Pull/Legs)
    • Description (Body Part Split with high frequency): Instead of one "chest day" per week, an advanced lifter might use a body part split where they hit a muscle group directly once, but indirectly (through compound movements) later in the week, ensuring at least 2x/week frequency.
    • Why it's "Best": Allows for extremely high training volume and focus on individual muscle groups. The ability to handle this volume and frequency without overtraining is a hallmark of advanced lifters. It offers immense flexibility for prioritizing lagging body parts.
    • Evidence: While often criticized for low frequency (when done as 1x/week), advanced lifters can manipulate body part splits to achieve higher effective frequencies and very high localized volume. Some advanced individuals may find this allows for maximal focus on individual muscles within a session. However, the core principle of hitting muscles 2x/week still holds for most advanced lifters seeking hypertrophy.

Key Takeaways and How to Choose

  1. Prioritize Frequency: For hypertrophy, hitting each muscle group at least twice per week is a robust, evidence-backed recommendation for most individuals.
  2. Match to Experience:
    • Novices: Start with Full Body (2-3x/week). It's efficient, builds motor patterns, and maximizes rapid early gains.
    • Intermediates: Upper/Lower (4x/week) or PPL (5-6x/week) are excellent choices, offering a good balance of frequency, volume, and recovery.
    • Advanced: The "best" is highly individualized. Upper/Lower and PPL still work. More specialised Body Part Splits can work if frequency is maintained and volume is carefully managed.
  3. Consider Your Schedule: Be realistic about how many days you can consistently commit. Missing workouts due to an overly ambitious split is counterproductive.
  4. Progressive Overload is King: Regardless of your split, the fundamental driver of progress is progressive overload, consistently increasing the demands on your muscles over time (more weight, reps, sets, or improved form).
  5. Listen to Your Body: Pay attention to recovery, sleep, and nutrition. If you're constantly fatigued or experiencing joint pain, your volume or frequency might be too high, or your recovery inadequate.
  6. Experiment (Responsibly): Once you have a foundational understanding, don't be afraid to try different splits for a few months to see what you respond best to, while always adhering to the principles of frequency and progressive overload.

By using this evidence-based framework, you can select a workout split that aligns with your experience level and lifestyle, setting you up for sustainable and effective progress in your fitness journey.